Participants of the seminar for judges and lawyers organized by the "Union of European Rights". Lusine Akopyan (left), Chair of the Union, Yerevan, November 1-3, 2011. Courtesy of Ela.am

07 November 2011, 22:50

In Armenia, rights defenders hold seminar on international standards on freedom of speech for judges and lawyers

In Yerevan, November 3 was the last day of the three-day seminar for judges and lawyers, organized by the Public Organization "Union of European Rights" with the support of the OSCE Office and US Embassy. According to the Chair of the "Union of European Rights", Armenian journalists, lawyers have very poor awareness in the sphere of the human right to the freedom of speech; and the seminar was aimed at repairing the situation.

As reported by the "Caucasian Knot" correspondent, the invited experts to the seminar were Gavin Miller, a member of the organization "Doughty Street Chambers", a British rights defender and a Royal Adviser, and Boiko Boevi, the chief lawyer of the well-known international organization in the sphere of the freedom of expression "Article 19".

According to the organizers, seminars are held at the background of the growing number of lawsuits against journalists and media professionals in Armenia. The aim of the seminar is to protect the freedom of expression and strengthen the awareness of the respective right in the society. The seminar dealt with the issues relating to libel and defamation, the right to have one's privacy duly respected, as well as the disrespect to the court and coverage of trials and freedom of speech in the context of elections.

The seminar brought together 20 Armenian judges and about the same number of lawyers.

According to Lusine Akopyan, Chair of the "Union of European Rights", the participants of the seminar were selected by her Union; those were the judges and lawyers who had run cases on libel and defamation. "We want to raise the awareness among judges and lawyers of Armenia on international standards on the freedom of speech, enabling us to achieve greater protection of our rights," she said.

The seminar was conducted separately for judges and included mostly presentations of the experts invited from abroad, and separately for lawyers - the core of this part was in case studies.

"The monitoring conducted by our Union has shown that journalists, lawyers and judges have a very low level of awareness of the human right to the freedom of speech. Our Constitution is very clear about these rights; however, in practice they are poorly applied," said Lusine Akopyan.

According to Alexander Sirunyan, Director of the Law Bureau, we cannot state categorically that there is no freedom of speech in Armenia. This is evidenced by the fact that anyone can write everything in social networks; and to this day there was not a single case, when someone was persecuted for that.

Olga Safaryan, a lawyer and the chair of the "Committee in Defence of the Freedom of Speech", finds such seminars, where the audience can compare their practices with the ECtHR, very useful.

According to her story, the Armenian legislation fully complies with international standards. "We have a problem with enforcement and application. The law is not always bad, but it should be correctly applied," said the lawyer.

She believes that the topic of libel and defamation is the most critical issue for Armenia, especially in anticipation of the upcoming elections.

The law specifies the amount of compensation for insult of up to 1 million drams (more than 2600 US dollars), and for libel - up to 2 million drams (more than 5200 US dollars).

"As a rule, the courts make use of the maximum sanction, for unknown reasons," said Safaryan. "Usually, a lawsuit may have both slander and defamation. The courts collect, apart from these 3 million drams, also the court costs. That is, any newspaper may be easily driven into bankruptcy. For Armenia, this is quite a topical problem."

The lawyer has also noted that the results of the last quarterly monitoring of Armenia's courts revealed about 30 lawsuits on libel and defamation. They are filed against media mainly by oligarchs and MPs, and, in practice, "the law on libel and defamation has turned against media, as all the oligarchs' lawsuits have been satisfied," said Safaryan.

She said that the Armenian Ombudsperson Karen Andreasyan had appealed to the Constitutional Court in order to define whether this law is consistent or inconsistent with the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia. The hearing is scheduled for November 15, 2011.

Author: Armine Martirosyan Source: CK correspondent

Комментирование через Кавказский узел
All news
НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН И РАСПРОСТРАНЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ ООО “МЕМО”, ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА ООО “МЕМО”.

April 03, 2025 22:57

  • Relatives of political prisoners announce 24-hour protest in Tbilisi

    Families of oppositionists arrested in connection with participation in pro-European protest actions have united in a public movement to demand the release of prisoners of conscience. The activists plan to start a 24-hour protest action in front of the parliament building in Tbilisi.

April 03, 2025 22:13

  • Sister of convicted Rizvanov demands answer about legality of law enforcers’ visits

    Two men came to the house of the parents of Abubakar Rizvanov, who was sentenced to imprisonment in a case on terrorism financing, and demanded the information about the place of residence of his children. A sister of Abubakar Rizvanov regarded the constant visits by law enforcers as pressure and demanded an answer about the legality of their actions.

April 03, 2025 21:58

April 02, 2025 22:55

  • Verdict to Sochi resident Schus upheld

    The appellate court has refused to change the sentence passed to Alexei Schus, a Sochi engineer, convicted on charges of spreading fake news about the Russian Army and making a slingshot.

April 02, 2025 21:15

  • Kurban Dalgatov's mother assess trial prospects of her son's death case

    The law enforcers guilty of the death of Kurban Dalgatov, a Makhachkala resident, are trying in every way to avoid punishment, while the judges are following their lead, the mother of Kurban, who died after being tortured by the police. The trial of Dalgatov's death case will continue on April 30 this year.

News archive
Пн
Вт
Ср
Чт
Пт
Сб
Вс
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
1
2
3
4